Shasta Daisy vs Oxeye Daisy: How to Tell the Difference and Choose the Right One for Your Garden

//

Robby

“He loves me, he loves me not.” The classic daisy is actually more than just the topic of a childhood rhyme. From Celtic legends to Ancient Roman mythology, different types of daisies have long been revered as symbols of purity, love, and transformation.

Did you know that the name “daisy” comes from the term “day’s eye?” This name is derived from the fact that the head of the common daisy closes at night, and re-opens in the morning.

Most people think of daisies as the classic white flower bearing a yellow center and adorned with long delicate petals. However, there are many types of daisies that exist today ranging from the exotic “Crazy” Shasta daisy to the colorful Gerber Daisy. These daisy types come in a wide assortment of colors and shapes, and are a far stretch from the classic white daisy that we all know.

With its classic yellow center and long white petals, the English daisy is also referred to as the common daisy. With its origins in Northern Europe, this hardy perennial has been distributed widely around the world. In the United States, it has unfortunately become a common weed. However, there are many other varieties of daisies bred from the English daisy that have a much better reputation, and can be found in the Bellis genus.

The Shasta daisy is another classic daisy that bears a very similar resemblance to the English daisy. The Shasta daisy, however, has a much larger yellow center and grows much taller, often reaching stem heights of two to three feet tall. Although popular in the United States, the Shasta daisy did not come into existence on its own. It was bred as a hybrid by a botanist named Luther Burbank, in Mt. Shasta, California, using three other daisies including the wild Oxeye daisy, also from the Leucanthemum family.

The Gerber daisy is one of the world’s most popular daisies. Available in a large variety of bright colors and showy flower heads, these daisies have become widely cultivated. Exotic cultivars include the Lollipop Gerber daisy, which has a large flower head that consists of a thick inner circle of petals that’s oftentimes a different color from its outer petals. Because Gerber daisies are so unique, they have formed their own genus called the Gerbera genus.

The Painted daisy is a very popular daisy in gardens, due to their ability to attract butterflies. Its fern-like leaves make it an attractive plant even after the flowers have bloomed. They are also quite effective at repelling pesky insects and are virtually disease-free. The Painted daisy comes in a variety of bright colors including, white, red, purple, and pink and which are all part of the Chrysanthemum genus.

Scientifically known as Leucanthemum vulgare, the oxeye daisy is a wildflower that shares its European origins with the English daisy. Its wild nature lends itself to spreading easily, and being drought tolerant. Although beautiful, the oxeye daisy has been known to plague the fields and pastures of Europe where today it is considered a common weed.

Daisies are charming, classic flowers that can brighten up any garden. With their iconic white petals and bright yellow centers, they epitomize the cheerfulness of summertime. However not all daisies are created equal. Two popular daisy varieties – Shasta daisy and oxeye daisy – may look similar at first glance but have some key differences. Knowing how to distinguish these two plants is important as oxeye daisy is considered a noxious weed in many areas.

What is a Shasta Daisy?

Shasta daisy (Leucanthemum x superbum) is a hybrid flower bred by horticulturist Luther Burbank in the 1890s. Burbank crossed European and American daisies to create a robust plant with elegant white blooms and lush, deep green foliage.

Some key features of Shasta daisies:

  • Grows 2-3 feet tall with a 1-2 foot spread
  • Large flowers up to 5 inches across with bright yellow centers
  • Dark green leaves up to 4 inches long that are not deeply lobed
  • Blooms throughout summer
  • Perennial in zones 4-9

Shasta daisies make excellent cut flowers and also attract pollinators to the garden While they spread slowly, forming clumps over time, they generally won’t become invasive.

What is Oxeye Daisy?

Oxeye daisy (Leucanthemum vulgare) is a European native plant that has naturalized in North America. Also known as common daisy or dog daisy, oxeye daisy features similar white and yellow flowers but has some distinct differences from Shasta daisy:

  • Grows 1-3 feet tall with a bushy, spreading habit
  • Smaller flowers around 2 inches wide
  • Deeply lobed, toothed leaves 2-6 inches long
  • Blooms spring through summer
  • Short-lived perennial but self-seeds readily
  • Considered a noxious weed in many states

One major issue with oxeye daisy is its aggressive spreading habit. Each plant can produce over 200 seeds, which allows it to quickly colonize open areas. Oxeye daisy tends to choke out native plants and create single-species stands where diversity once flourished. For this reason, it is banned in some states and discouraged from being planted in gardens.

How to Tell Shasta and Oxeye Daisies Apart

Telling Shasta and oxeye daisies apart does take some close inspection. Here are a few tips:

  • Size: Shasta daisies grow significantly taller, up to 2-3 feet compared to 1-2 feet for oxeye daisy.

  • Leaves: Shasta daisy leaves are long, narrow and not deeply cut. Oxeye daisy has deeply lobed, toothed leaves.

  • Flowers: Shasta daisies have larger blooms, around 4-5 inches wide versus 2 inches for oxeye.

  • Habit: Oxeye daisy is a vigorous spreader that expands rapidly. Shasta daisy stays neatly clumped.

  • Classification: Oxeye daisy is considered a noxious weed in some states, while Shasta daisy is solely grown ornamentally.

Should You Grow Oxeye Daisy?

In general, oxeye daisy should be avoided in home gardens. While it does produce lovely white flowers over a long bloom period, its aggressive habit makes it poorly suited for cultivated spaces. Oxeye daisy can quickly escape the garden by self-seeding and become a nuisance in the broader landscape. It also crosses readily with other daisy relatives, creating hybrids that can also spread.

Instead of oxeye daisy, choose alternative daisy varieties or flowers from the extensive Asteraceae family. Some options include:

  • Shasta daisy – iconic, elegant blooms that stay where planted
  • Echinacea (coneflower) – vibrant pink or white flowers; drought tolerant
  • Rudbeckia (black-eyed Susan) – bright yellow, long lasting blossoms
  • Gaillardia (blanket flower) – bold red and yellow flowers on compact plants
  • Coreopsis – abundant delicate yellow or white daisy-like flowers

How to Grow Shasta Daisies

Shasta daisies make an excellent substitute for oxeye daisies in perennial gardens. They provide the same classic daisy look but are better behaved. Here are some tips for growing Shasta daisies:

  • Sun: Plant in full sun for best flowering; will tolerate light shade.

  • Soil: Average garden soil with good drainage; avoid overly wet soil.

  • Planting: Start with nursery transplants in spring after the last frost. Space 12-24 inches apart.

  • Care: Provide moderate water when first establishing. Mature plants are quite drought tolerant. Fertilize lightly in spring if needed.

  • Division: Clumps can be divided every 2-3 years in spring or fall to rejuvenate.

  • Hardiness: Rated for zones 4-9; provide winter mulch in colder climates.

  • Pests/problems: Generally pest and disease free, but may be affected by powdery mildew, Septoria leaf spot, or stem rot in excessively damp conditions. Slugs may chew leaves.

The Best Blooms for Your Garden

When choosing daisies for your garden, opt for well-behaved beauties like the Shasta daisy over potentially invasive oxeye daisy. Pay close attention when purchasing daisy plants, as some wildflower mixes may contain oxeye daisy. With its elegant blossoms and easy care nature, Shasta daisy is sure to become a treasured part of the summer garden.

shasta daisy vs oxeye daisy

How Daisy Types are Classified

To illustrate just how expansive the daisy family is, we’ve created a comprehensive outline of how the most popular daisies are taxonomically classified, accompanied with a visual compendium that includes 94 of the world’s most popular daisies.

Family: Asteraceae

The daisy belongs to the Asteraceae family. With over 1,500 genera and 23,000 species, it is the largest family of flowering plants. Daisies share this family along with sunflowers, chrysanthemums and even lettuce! Flowers belonging to the daisy family are characterized by a single flower head composed of many tiny flowers (sometimes over a hundred) called florets, which are surrounded by rays of longer petals. The “aster” in Asteraceae refers to the resulting star-shaped construction of the flower heads belonging to this family. Because there are two flowers that make up one, the Asteraceae family is commonly referred to as the Compositae or “composite” family.

Subfamily: Asteroideae

The Asteroideae subfamily contains over 70% of the species in the entire Asteraceae family. It contains over 21 tribes, including: Astereae, Anthemideae, Calenduleae, Heliantheae, and Perityleae, which include most types of daisies.

Tribe: Astereae

The Astereae tribe consists of over 2,800 species and includes many of the most recognizable daisy flowers we all know. Many of these daisies are classified into various genera, including: Bellis, Chaetopappa, and Townsendia.

Genus: Arctotis Native to Africa, many of these flowers have now become naturalized in the United States. Some daisies within this genus are stemless, such as the Arctotis acaulis. The name Arctotis is derived from the Greek word “arktos”, meaning bear, which could refer to the shaggy hairs found on the fruit.

Genus: Bellis The Bellis genus includes the common daisy, also known as the English daisy (Bellis perennis), as well as other common daisy species. The common daisy originated in Europe, and its popularity fueled its distribution across the globe to the United States, where today it has become a common weed. Characterized by a rich yellow center with rays of long white petals, the flowers in this genus have the quintessential characteristics we all recognize in a classic daisy.

Genus: Monoptilon Known as the desert star, or daisy desertstar, these types of daisies are native to the southwest desert of the United States. Most commonly found in the Mojave Desert, the desertstar is a small wildflower that thrives in dry and open areas and begin to flower in late winter.

Genus: Townsendia Known as the Townsend Daisies, the name Townsendia is derived from the birthplace of the man who discovered this genus of daisies. William Jackson Hooker made his discovery in 1833, and was from a town called Townsend, Pennsylvania. All 25 species of Townsend daisies are native to western North America and flourish in dryer climates.

Tribe: Anthemideae The tribe Anthemideae contains 111 genera and approximately 1800 species. Members of this tribe have mostly originated from Central Asia, the Mediterranean and Southern Africa. Many of these plants have natural compounds that act as anti-infectious agents and are used in pharmaceuticals.

Genus: Argyranthemum Known as the marguerite daisies (Argyranthemum frutescens), all of the subspecies within this genus are cultivars that have resulted from hybridization. These daisies are effective at attracting butterflies, and have become quite popular in gardening due to their wide array of colors.

Genus: Chrysanthemum The Chrysanthemum gets its name from the Greek words “chrysos”, meaning gold, and “anthemom”, meaning flower. This is because the first chrysanthemums that appeared in China were golden-colored and were used for their herbal healing properties that ranged from reducing high blood pressure to lowering cholesterol. A common synonym for this genus is Tanacetum, and the two names are used interchangeably. The most common daisy in the Chrysanthemum genus is the painted daisy (Tanacetum coccineum).

Genus: Leucanthemum This genus is home to the oxeye daisy (Leucanthemum vulgare), a wild daisy that gave rise to the Shasta daisy (Leucanthemum x superbum). This species was developed by Luther Burbank who crossed a European oxeye daisy with three other Leucanthemum daisies plus a Japanese field daisy. Today, the Shasta daisy is the most popular daisy in this genus from which many other ornamental cultivars have been bred.

Tribe: Calenduleae The Calenduleae tribe is one of the smaller tribes of the Asteraceae family. Flowers within this tribe usually have quite showy flower heads, and the plant types within this tribe vary from herbs to shrubs. The tribe gets its name from Calendula – an anti-inflammatory substance that is present within the petals of marigolds, which belong to the Calendula genus within this tribe. Although the Calendula genus mostly includes marigolds, there are several daisy types within this tribe that belong to the Osteospermum genus.

Genus: Osteospermum Also known as the “daisybushes”, these perennial daisies are native to Africa. However, due to their popularity, these African daisies have been distributed around the world and many exotic cultivars have been bred. Most of these cultivars are hybridizations of the two main Osteospermum species: Osteopermum jucundum and Osteopermum ecklonis. Daisies belonging to this genus are not to be confused with the Dimorphotheca – which look highly similar but are annuals instead of perennials.

Tribe: Heliantheae There are 2,500 species within this tribe, with the most recognizable being the sunflower. Other common plants include echinacea, stevia and zinnias. Besides flowers, many of the plants in this tribe are also shrubs and herbs that grow in dryer climates.

Genus: Echinacea Also known as coneflowers, flowers belonging to this genus exhibit prickly spines on the flower head. Its name is actually derived from the Greek word “echinos”, meaning sea urchin or hedgehog. These drought-tolerant plants are well-known for their medicinal properties and are used in herbal remedies.

Subfamily: Mutisioideae This subfamily contains 44 genera and 630 species. Plants from this subfamily are primarily found in South America, with the exception of three genera – the most popular of which is the Gerbera genus.

Tribe: Mutisieae The Mutisieae tribe is one of three major tribes of the Mutisioideae subfamily, containing 14 genera and 200 species. There has been much debate as to the lineage of this particular tribe, however recent research has suggested that plants belonging to this tribe are differentiated enough from the other existing tribes to be classified as its own group.

Genus: Gerbera Originating from Africa, daisies from this genus are largely cultivated around the world today for their showy flowers. Most cultivars of the gerbera daisies that we see today are hybrids of Gerbera jamesonii and Gerbera viridifolia. These two daisy species are also known as Transvaal or African daisies due to their origins in South Africa. The name Gerber refers to Thomas A. Gerbera, a botanist who traveled around Europe studying plants.

Types of Daisies Compendium

As you can see, daisies have origins that range from Europe to China, and from Africa all the way to North America. To illustrate the scope of all the different daisy varieties that exist, we’ve created a compendium of the most popular daisies that shows how these flowers are categorized.

Who knew that the world of daisies could be so vast? It’s clear to see that the name “daisy” does not only pertain to the classic white flower with the yellow center. If you’re feeling inspired by daisies, you can browse our daisy bouquets, which feature the beautiful Gerbera daisies mentioned in this guide! If you’d like to know more about other types of flowers, we’ve also created other visual compendiums for types of roses and types of orchids as well.

Shasta Daisy -The longest blooming flowering perennial?

FAQ

Is oxeye daisy an invasive plant?

Ox-eye daisy is an aggressive invasive species. Once established, it can spread rapidly by means of roots and seeds into undisturbed meadows, woodlands, and riparian areas. It forms dense stands that tend to displace native vegetation, especially wildflowers.

How to identify a Shasta daisy?

erect clump, sparsely branched, about 3 feet tall. alternate, long-oblanceolate, coarsel and bluntly toothed. solitary heads on long stalks, flowers are about 3-4 inches across, ray flowers white and disc flowers yellow.

What is another name for the Oxeye Daisy?

Leucanthemum vulgare, commonly known as the ox-eye daisy, oxeye daisy, dog daisy, marguerite (French: Marguerite commune, “common marguerite”) and other common names, is a widespread flowering plant native to Europe and the temperate regions of Asia, and an introduced plant to North America, Australia and New Zealand.

Should I remove Oxeye daisy?

(pulling, cutting, disking) Small patches may be removed with hand tools or by repeated hand-pulling. Mowing before bloom can reduce seed set but will not control the plant. Mowing during or after flowering will disperse seeds. Because of its shallow root system, oxeye daisy can be controlled with cultivation.

Leave a Comment