Ideal for spring and fall gardens, cruciferous vegetables have unique growing needs. Heres everything you need to know about these cool weather veggies.
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
Have you ever heard the terms cruciferous vegetables, Brassica vegetables, and cole crops used interchangeably and wondered “What the heck?” You’re not alone. I’ve also been slightly flummoxed by their use for the same vegetable.
There is, it turns out, a reason for the confusion. But Im here to clarify exactly what cruciferous vegetables are and how to grow these cold weather vegetables successfully in your garden.
When it comes to healthy, nutrient-dense vegetables, spinach and brassicas like kale, broccoli, and cabbage are staples But is spinach actually classified as a brassica vegetable? Let’s explore the distinct properties of spinach and brassicas to uncover where spinach truly belongs
Understanding Plant Families: Where Does Spinach Fit In?
To understand why spinach isn’t a brassica we first need to look at how plants are scientifically classified into families based on shared evolutionary ancestry and physical characteristics.
The Amaranthaceae Family: Spinach’s True Home
Spinach belongs to the Amaranthaceae family, which also includes beets, chard, quinoa, and amaranth. Members of this family typically have simple leaves, small flowers arranged in clusters, and often vibrant coloration. Their seeds tend to be small and lens-shaped.
The Brassicaceae Family: Cabbage and Its Cousins
The Brassicaceae family, also known as the Cruciferae family, encompasses familiar vegetables like broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, kale, Brussels sprouts, turnips, and radishes. These plants share unique traits like four-petaled flowers arranged in a cross shape (hence the name “Cruciferae”), pungent sulfur compounds called glucosinolates, and an affinity for cool climates.
Key Differences: Spinach vs. Brassicas
Beyond their taxonomic classification, spinach and brassica vegetables differ significantly in appearance, growth habits, nutritional content, and culinary use.
Morphological Distinctions
While both can produce leafy greens, spinach and brassica leaves have distinct shapes and textures. Spinach leaves are generally smooth or slightly crinkled, growing in a flat rosette. Brassica leaves vary widely, from tightly wrapped cabbage heads to ruffled kale leaves.
Chemical Composition: Glucosinolates and More
The most notable difference is in their chemical makeup. Brassicas contain glucosinolates, sulfur compounds that break down into health-promoting isothiocyanates. Spinach lacks glucosinolates, instead containing higher levels of oxalates, which can inhibit mineral absorption.
Nutritional Profiles: Similarities and Divergences
Both offer abundant vitamins and minerals, but their nutritional profiles differ. They share high levels of vitamin K, A, and folate, but spinach has more iron and magnesium, while some brassicas are very high in vitamin C and fiber.
Why the Confusion?
There are a few reasons spinach and brassicas are sometimes lumped together:
-
Both are leafy greens, leading to a casual categorization.
-
Their overlapping nutritional benefits blur perceived differences.
-
They share versatile culinary applications, working both raw and cooked.
But scientifically, spinach’s distinct family lineage, physical traits, and chemical composition definitively set it apart from the brassica group.
Frequently Asked Questions
To clarify the spinach-brassica relationship, here are answers to common questions:
What are the major health benefits of spinach?
Spinach provides vitamin K, A, C, folate, iron, magnesium, lutein, zeaxanthin, and more. It has anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects.
What are the major health benefits of brassica vegetables?
Brassicas offer fiber, vitamins C, K, A, and folate. Their glucosinolates have anti-cancer, antioxidant, and anti-inflammatory properties.
Should I be concerned about consuming too much spinach?
Spinach’s oxalates can bind minerals like calcium. Those prone to kidney stones should moderate intake. Cooking reduces oxalates.
Are there any risks with eating lots of brassica vegetables?
Very high raw brassica intake can affect thyroid function in those with iodine deficiencies. Cooking negates this.
Can I substitute spinach for brassicas?
You can substitute spinach, but flavor and texture will differ. Spinach is milder and more delicate than robust, bitter brassicas.
How do I store spinach and brassicas?
Store unwashed spinach in the fridge in a breathable bag. Store brassicas loosely wrapped; use sturdy ones like cabbage soon.
Is organic or conventional produce better?
While organic reduces pesticide exposure, conventional and organic have similar nutrition. Buying local is a budget-friendly alternative.
What are easy ways to eat more spinach and brassicas?
Add spinach to smoothies, eggs, soups, and sautés. Roast brassicas, add to slaws and soups, or sauté kale.
Are all leafy greens healthy?
Generally yes! All leafy greens provide low-calorie vital nutrients and antioxidants. Eating a variety is ideal.
The Verdict
While spinach and brassicas share some traits, spinach definitively does not belong to the brassica family. Their distinct flavors, textures, nutrition, and culinary versatility make both valuable additions to a healthy diet. By understanding their unique botanical backgrounds, we gain appreciation for their diverse health benefits.
Is It a Cole Crop, Brassica or Cruciferous Veggie?
It turns out that all the members of these groups are all the same species, so why the different names? No, no one is deliberately trying to confuse you (or me), it just has to do with an advancement in historical classifications.
At one point, the members of this species were all categorized under the family name Cruciferae. This family contains 372 genera and 4,060 different species. Within this large family reside cruciferous veggies such as Brassica oleracea which includes broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, collards, and kale. Other Brassicaceae members also have a place within the Cruciferae family.
Because the Cruciferae family is so large and diverse, scientists decided to subdivide it and make Brassica members their own family. The genus name (Brassicaceae) comes from the Latin for cruciferous vegetables. The older nomenclature, Cruciferae, means “cross-bearing” and is a reference to the four cross shaped petals of mustard blooms. ( credit: Getty s)
What about cole crops? Cole crop is an older term for these same Brassica or cruciferous vegetables used primarily in the agricultural trade.
What Are Cruciferous Vegetables?
Hopefully that enlightened rather than confused anyone. Suffice it to say a Brassica is a cruciferous vegetable and vice versa.Gardening tips, videos, info and more delivered right to your inbox!
Sign up for the Gardening Know How newsletter today and receive a free copy of our e-book “How to Grow Delicious Tomatoes”. Contact me with news and offers from other Future brands Receive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors
That said, there is yet room for confusion since which crops are considered to be in this family varies depending upon what cruciferous vegetable list you consult.
Brassica or cruciferous veggies (cole crops) come in an array of shapes, sizes, and colors to the extent that it seems as if they have nothing in common which isn’t true. All Brassica are cool season veggies. Most bear flowers that are made up of four petals resembling a cross. While they may be cultivated for leaves, flower buds or even roots, Brassica are all nutrient rich and high in fiber.
Also, while over time, Brassica veggies have evolved they do have a common ancestor; wild cabbage. ( credit: Marina Zezelina / Shutterstock)
Broadly, cruciferous vegetables belong to the Cruciferae family, which mostly contains the Brassica genus, but does include a few other genuses. In general, cruciferous vegetables are cool weather vegetables and have flowers that have four petals so that they resemble a cross.
In most cases, the leaves or flower buds of cruciferous vegetables are eaten, but there are a few where either the roots or seeds are also eaten.